The 16 Best Custom Cookies in San Francisco

Golden Gate Fortune Cookie Factory is a renowned cookie shop offering a unique experience in San Francisco. They provide a variety of services such as kerbside pickup, delivery, in-store pick-up, in-store shopping, and takeaway. The business is known for its delightful desserts and friendly environment, making it a popular choice for both locals and tourists.

• Customers appreciate the traditional atmosphere and quality of the fortune cookies.
• Visitors love the free samples and the opportunity to see how the cookies are made.
• The staff is friendly and knowledgeable, providing a unique and enjoyable shopping experience.
• Many customers highly recommend a visit to the Golden Gate Fortune Cookie Factory when in Chinatown.

Hot Cookie is a popular cookie shop located in San Francisco. They offer a wide range of delicious cookies that are sure to satisfy any sweet tooth. Customers rave about the friendly and helpful service they receive at Hot Cookie, as well as the variety of cookie flavors available.

Some key points from customer reviews include:

• The colorful sugar cookies are a must-try and worth the calories.
• Customers appreciate the affordable prices and warm, welcoming environment.
• Visitors love the soft and flavorful cookies, with a perfect balance between moist and crumbly texture.
• Many customers recommend stopping by Hot Cookie while in the Castro district for a treat that is still yummy the next morning.

With kerbside pickup, delivery, and in-store shopping options available, Hot Cookie makes it easy to enjoy their scrumptious cookies wherever you are. If you're in the area, be sure to visit this LGBTQ+ friendly cookie shop for a delightful and unforgettable treat!

Anthony's Cookies is a beloved cookie shop located in San Francisco, CA. This cozy bakery offers a variety of delicious treats that keep customers coming back for more. With a rating of 4.5 stars, it's clear that patrons are impressed with what they find here.

• The traditional chocolate chip cookies are a standout favorite, with many patrons raving about their taste.
• Customers appreciate the variety of flavors available, including unique options like choc dipped vegan shortbread and chocolate covered peanut butter.
• Many reviewers mention the friendly and neighborly service they received, making their visit feel welcoming and pleasant.
• While some felt that the cookies were a bit smaller for the price, the overall quality and flavor of the treats made up for it.

Whether you're popping in for a quick visit or looking to enjoy some dessert with friends, Anthony's Cookies has something for everyone. Don't miss out on the chance to indulge in some of the best cookies in town!

Flour & Fleur Cookies is a delightful bakery that crafts exquisite custom cookies for special occasions. Customers rave about the stunning designs and mouth-watering taste of the cookies. From birthdays to bachelorette parties, Flour & Fleur Cookies adds a special touch to any event.

Here are some key points from customer reviews:

• The cookies were not only adorable but also larger and more delicious than expected, making them a hit at the party.
• Customers praised Alyssa's kindness and attention to detail, creating perfect cookies that wowed guests.
• Whether for baby showers or engagement parties, Alyssa's custom cookies are a must-have for any celebration.
• Many customers appreciated the quick turnaround and responsiveness of Flour & Fleur Cookies, making them their go-to place for beautiful treats.

Experience the magic of Flour & Fleur Cookies at your next event and indulge in the perfect blend of charm and taste.

City Gal Bakes is a popular bakery in San Francisco that offers a wide range of services to its customers. They provide Kerbside pickup, No-contact delivery, Delivery, and In-store pick-up options, making it convenient for everyone. Customers rave about their experience, giving them a perfect rating of 5.0 stars.

• The cookies are not only delicious but also delightful, with unique decorations that match any occasion perfectly.
• The quality of instruction in their classes is outstanding, allowing even those with no artistic talent to create adorable cookies.
• Customers appreciate the attention to detail, creativity, and exceptional customer service provided by City Gal Bakes.

If you're looking for top-tier baked goods that taste amazing and look like edible masterpieces, give City Gal Bakes a try for your next event!

Delights by Lisa is a charming bakery located in San Francisco, CA. They offer a variety of service options including in-store shopping, takeout, and in-store pick-up. Customers can enjoy wheelchair-accessible entrance and make payments conveniently with credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

This bakery has received high ratings and positive reviews from satisfied customers. Here are some key points from their feedback:

• Best cakes and desserts ever, the morning puff pastry and cupcakes are delicious.
• Custom cakes must be ordered in advance, with incredible attention to detail and prompt communication.
• The most delicious red velvet cake, great communication, meticulous cake design, and attention to detail.
• Delicious blueberry muffins, mini quiche, and the best cupcakes in San Francisco.

If you are looking for custom cakes for special occasions and delightful snacks, Delights by Lisa is the perfect choice in San Francisco. Let Lisa and her team create a memorable and delicious experience for you!

Bri's Creations Cake and Pastries Boutique is a charming bakery located in San Francisco that offers a range of delicious treats and services. Customers can enjoy options such as delivery, in-store pick-up, and takeaway. The bakery is known for its wheelchair-accessible entrance, providing accessibility for all.

With a rating of 4.9 based on 24 reviews, customers have shared their positive experiences. Some key points from the reviews include:

• A Hello Kitty cake that was not only delicious but also matched the customer's design idea perfectly, thanks to exceptional customer service.
• An array of handcrafted desserts that were a huge hit at a holiday gathering, showcasing the variety and quality of Bri's creations.
• A beautifully done cake for a birthday that received compliments for its taste, moistness, and elegant appearance, ensuring repeat orders in the future.
• A delightful haven for pastry enthusiasts with a cozy ambiance, attention to detail, and commitment to creativity and freshness that sets Bri's Creations apart in the culinary landscape.

Customers praise the bakery for its commitment to quality, creativity, and exceptional customer service. Whether you're looking for a custom cake, pastries, or an indulgent treat, Bri's Creations Cake and Pastries Boutique is a must-visit destination for a delightful culinary experience.

My Baking Creations (Cake Shop Bakery) is a delightful bakery that offers a wide range of tasty treats and beautiful custom cakes. With services like kerbside pickup, delivery, and in-store pick-up, customers can enjoy their favorite sweets with ease. The bakery is also LGBTQ+ friendly and welcomes everyone with open arms.

• Customers rave about the personalized service they received, noting the prompt responses and attention to detail.
• The cakes are not only visually stunning but also delicious, making them a hit at any event.
• Many customers appreciate the variety of flavors offered, ensuring there is something for everyone to enjoy.
• The ability to create custom cookies and cake pops with logos for corporate events has also been a big hit with businesses looking to impress.

Melzee's Cookie Co. is a delightful cookie shop that offers beautifully crafted and delicious cookies for any occasion. Customers rave about the attention to detail and the fantastic taste of the cookies. Here are some key points from customer reviews:

• Customers loved the cookies for their tastiness and adorable designs.
• The owner, Melissa, is praised for her responsiveness, coordination, and execution of custom cookie orders.
• The presentation of the cookies in individual packaging and secure window boxes for easy pickup was well-appreciated by customers.
• Supporting a local, woman-owned small business like Melzee's Cookie Co. is a big plus for customers.

Book your order today and experience the joy of delicious and beautifully designed cookies from Melzee's Cookie Co.

Hot Cookie Bakery is a delightful spot in San Francisco that offers a range of mouthwatering treats. Their menu includes a variety of cookies that are sure to satisfy any sweet tooth. Customers rave about the quality and flavor of the cookies, with many highlighting the large size of the cookies and their reasonable prices.

• The white chicken macadamia cookie was described as addictive and freshly baked, creating a truly enjoyable experience.
• Visitors appreciate the friendly staff and the warm, welcoming atmosphere that adds to the overall charm of the bakery.
• Customers also enjoy the creativity and unique flavors of the cookies, such as the chocolate chip toffee and spicy cocoa cookies.
• Many reviewers mention that a visit to Hot Cookie is a must when in the area, and that the cookies are perfect for satisfying a sweet craving or for a fun and indulgent treat.

Sweet Things Bakery is a delightful spot in San Francisco that offers a wide range of delicious pastries and cakes. Customers can enjoy delivery, in-store pick-up, and takeaway options for their convenience. The bakery is known for its wheelchair-accessible car park and entrance, making it accessible to all. With quick visits, customers can grab their favorite treats in no time and enjoy the credit card and debit card payment options available.

The reviews speak highly of Sweet Things Bakery:

• An honest reviewer found the birthday cake dry and heavy, not recommending it to others.
• Another customer raved about the delicious pastries and outstanding service.
• A satisfied patron praised the helpful staff and the amazing carrot cake for a special occasion.
• A happy customer appreciated the manager's assistance in ordering a cake for a wedding celebration.

Visitors have consistently rated their experiences positively, highlighting the quality of the baked goods and the exceptional customer service offered at Sweet Things Bakery. If you're in search of delectable treats in San Francisco, this bakery is a must-visit!

Insomnia Cookies is a beloved cookie shop in San Francisco that offers a variety of delectable treats. Customers have praised the delivery, in-store pick-up, and takeaway options available. The dessert selection is outstanding, with vegan and gluten-free choices as well as classic options.

• Lots of options available for all preferences
• Fresh and delicious cookies with vegan and gluten-free choices
• Great customer service and welcoming atmosphere

One customer mentioned the challenge of ordering for delivery due to the fragile nature of the cookies, but praised the taste of the vegan double chocolate option. Another customer highly recommended visiting the store in person to enjoy the cookies at their best and shared tips on heating them up. While some customers have mentioned issues with the service quality at a specific location, many have expressed their appreciation for the exceptional customer service received at Insomnia Cookies.

Novela Cakes is a popular bakery located in San Francisco, CA. They offer a variety of services including delivery, in-store pick-up, and takeaway. Customers can enjoy delicious cakes and pastries made with high-quality ingredients.

With a rating of 4.4 stars, Novela Cakes has received positive reviews from satisfied customers. Some key points from the customer reviews include:

• Amazing creations, delicious and neatly done.
• Reasonable prices, beautifully decorated cakes, and pastries.
• Excellent service, high-quality products, and delicious desserts.
• Delicious and unforgettable cakes that are worth trying.

Visit Novela Cakes for a delightful experience and treat yourself to some of the best cakes in town!

Ultimate Cookie Inc. is a renowned bakery located in San Francisco, CA. They offer a wide range of delicious cookies that are loved by many customers. The business is women-owned and provides options for delivery and takeaway. Their location has a wheelchair-accessible entrance for the convenience of all customers.

Customers have praised the quality of products and the friendly staff at Ultimate Cookie Inc. Here are some key points from customer reviews:

• Unprofessional and rude behavior from a salesperson negatively impacted a customer's experience.
• High protein peanut butter bars are highly recommended for being vegan and delicious.
• Customers appreciate the quality of products and find the staff very friendly.

Whether you are looking for a sweet treat for yourself or catering a special event, Ultimate Cookie Inc. is a fantastic choice for all your cookie needs. Check out their website for more information and be sure to visit to try their amazing cookies!

Insomnia Cookies is a beloved cookie shop in San Francisco that offers a variety of delicious sweet treats. Customers have raved about the mint chocolate chip cookie, describing it as a delightful combination of minty freshness and rich chocolate. The exceptional customer service provided by the staff has also left a lasting impression on patrons.

Here are some key points from customer reviews:

• The mint chocolate chip cookie is a must-try for fans of this flavor combination.
• The staff is friendly, welcoming, and goes above and beyond to ensure customer satisfaction.
• The Oatmeal Chocolate Walnut Deluxe cookie is a favorite, warm, gooey, and full of flavor.
• While some customers have mentioned issues with pricing and sweetness levels, the majority have had positive experiences and highly recommend Insomnia Cookies.

Stirred, Not Shaken is a cookie shop located in San Francisco that offers a variety of delightful cookies for every taste. Customers can enjoy the convenience of kerbside pickup, delivery, in-store pick-up, and takeaway options. The shop is known for its delicious dessert options, making it a perfect spot for a quick visit.

With a solid rating of 4.0, Stirred, Not Shaken has received positive reviews from satisfied customers. Some key points highlighted in the reviews include:

• Best cookies ever with amazing flavors and generous portions.
• Soft and must-try cookies, especially the chocolate chip and M and Ms.
• Mixed experiences with delivery, hoping for a comeback.
• Delicious cookies, especially the bacon and molasses varieties.

Customers praise the shop for its top-notch customer service and delicious cookies that are a hit among cookie lovers in San Francisco. Give Stirred, Not Shaken a try for a sweet treat that will surely satisfy your cravings!